Amended Complaint Filed in the Superior Court of California

GAHT-US Corporation
Santa Monica, CA
September 18, 2014


Amended Complaint Filed in the Superior Court of California

Today the Plaintiffs in the lawsuit, Gingery et al. v. City of Glendale, BC556600, along with a new plaintiff, Masatoshi Naoki, filed an amended version of their original complaint, which was filed on September 3, 2014 with the Superior Court of the State of California, Los Angeles County. GAHT-US, one of the lawsuit’s plaintiffs, takes this opportunity to highlight certain aspects of the Amended Complaint, which above all strenuously demands that the City of Glendale removes the Comfort Women statue and its attached plaque.

The original complaint described the lack of City Council approval for the wording of the plaque, which GAHT-US finds offensive and one-sided. In the Amended Complaint, we add causes of action related to Glendale’s violation of the equal protection clause and privileges and immunities clauses of the California Constitution. Plaintiffs contend Glendale has deprived the Plaintiffs, and all its Japanese American citizens, of the equal protection of the laws and has offered them certain privileges and immunities on different terms than non-Japanese by installing the Comfort Women statue and plaque on city property, an action which we allege was due to coercion from a private group that had been formed specifically to erect anti-Japanese monuments in the U.S.

Plaintiffs contend that the Glendale monument unfairly accuses Americans of Japanese origin and descent of war crimes and “unconscionable violations of human rights.” In fact, scholars, elected officials, journalists and the general public around the world vigorously question and debate the nature and extent that the Japanese Imperial Military was involved with coercion and enslavement of women. GAHT-US deplores violence and injuries against the innocent wherever and whenever it occurs, but such accusations must not be made lightly.

As a result, GAHT-US contends that the City of Glendale has deprived its Japanese-American citizens of equal treatment under the law by interfering with their use and enjoyment of public facilities and public benefits. Specifically, plaintiffs Mrs. Gingery and Mr. Naoki are senior citizens and Japanese-American citizens who are unable to benefit on equal terms from the services offered to other senior citizens and Glendale residents.

As Plaintiffs explain in detail in their court filings, Glendale erected the Comfort Woman statue on public property that was reserved for all of Glendale’s sister cities in Japan, Armenia, Mexico and South Korea. Glendale presented the statue as a “Peace Monument” to honor sister cities. But instead of honoring all of its sister cities, Glendale mistakenly presented an unfair view of Japan and Japanese people by adopting a Comfort Women statue that presents a biased and anti-Japanese view of historical, political, and diplomatic issues between and among Japan, South Korea, and the United States.

The GAHT-US Corporation seeks peaceful and diplomatic resolutions of these issues, and does not wish to cause any international conflict. Rather, GAHT-US seeks friendly and honest relations among countries. We believe that such relations can be established only after the historical events are understood based on facts rather than fabrication, rumor, or political compromise. It is regrettable that litigation has become necessary to address these sensitive issues, but this lawsuit is a part of our overall activities intended to improve everyone’s understanding of our history. GAHT-US seeks to engage in a balanced discussion that protects equal rights and equal treatment for Japanese-American citizens of Glendale, and for all people.

Thank you for your interest in our activities.

Koichi Mera, Ph. D.
President, GAHT-US Corporation

gahtjp-admin について

日米に拠点を置くNPO法人、 国連での特別協議資格を保持 歴史の真実を世界に求め、世界に発信し、史実の誤解によって起こる国際紛争の解決を訴える